My husband knows I love interesting animal stories, so when he saw this one on DIGG about a 5,000 pound Devilfish (Giant Manta Ray) captured back in 1934, he sent it on to me.
This article came from the April, 1934 edition of Modern Mechanix. My first thought was WOW!. And I am aware that huge creatures live in the depths of the ocean such as the colossal squid. which is probably the source of the Kraken legend. But as I read the comments on this particular story, I got to wondering if this story accurate. One astute reader pointed out it was in the April edition...so perhaps it was an April Fool's joke.
So I went searching for the truth....
Ripley's Believe It Or Not, Snopes, and The Guiness World Book of Records all came up empty. Nada, Nothing! You would think that information about a 5000 pound Manta Ray would be there somewhere!
So then I checked out information on Manta Rays...
According to this information from an educational website. Baby mantas are hard to find, but they seem to be 4 feet across on average, much larger than the 18 inch baby shown in the photo.
According to this site, mantas do sometimes get tangled in anchor lines. Since they are only equipped for forward movement, they can reverse to extricate themselves. This article also says:
The largest recorded manta was taken off the coast of India. It measured 22 feet tip-to-tip and weighed in excess of two tons.
India is a long way from the coast of New Jersey. Also, most articles I have read, say the rays tend to feed at about 100-150 feet, not rarely coming up from the depths of the ocean as is stated in the article (but that could be ignorance of the time.
According to Wikipedia, the largest ever captured weighed 5000 pounds, but it doesn't give any other information which seems a bit suspicious to me. There is an alert at the top of the page that states some references and foot notes are missing. Articles also place manta rays in areas of tropical waters or temperate waters. I am not sure that the waters off of the New Jersey coast would qualify as temperate waters.
Other questions I have are...is it possible to shoot underwater using a rifle? I simply do not know. The article says the manta was put on exhibition, but does not say where, nor can I find any other reference to this remarkable creature! I can't imagine it not being found.
And then there is the question of why this article would have been in Modern Mechanix. Seems like an odd place for it to be written about.
So, there's where my research leads me...lots of questions, not many answers....What do you think?
Hoax? April Fool's Joke? Or Best Kept Secret?
http://www.melissaomarkham.com/2007/12/hoax_april_fools_joke_or_best.html